ALPACA farmers in Mobberley have won a six-year battle with their neighbours to retain a workers’ dwelling on their land.

Cheshire East Council has granted permission for Adrian and Joanna Hodgson to keep a wooden hut at White Peak Alpaca Farm despite it previously being subject to an enforcement notice.

The mobile home, in Paddock Hill Lane, was originally approved for three years in September 2005, but was never removed after the time limit expired.

This led to an appeal, which was thrown out by the Secretary of State in July 2010.

The council’s U-turn is expected to anger nearby residents, who say the green belt should be protected.

Clr David Bailey, chairman of Mobberley Parish Council, said: “If it’s a permanent dwelling it’s an unlawful development, and it should be removed immediately.

“If it’s a temporary dwelling, the time limit has expired.”

Mr Hodgson, 72, said the 60ft by 30ft timber building was essential to provide care for his 74 adult alpacas.

But objectors have questioned why Ivy Cottage cannot be used for the same purpose.

It is a property a quarter of a mile away from the farm, which was inherited by Mrs Hodgson.

Neighbour Heidi Gilks said: “They should have no problem financing the capital to renovate the cottage.

“This would go some way to safeguard the green belt.”

Planning officer Peter Hooley said despite the site’s history, the applicant had proved a need for the building and that it was financially viable.

A legal agreement is also being drafted, which is expected to see Ivy Cottage demolished as part of the conditions.

Mr Hodgson said: “My wife inherited Ivy Cottage, and it’s been the biggest white elephant ever since.

“You wouldn’t believe the stress it’s caused.

“It’s not suitable, that’s the thing. Every animal at certain times requires attention – we need to keep an eye on the pregnant females day and night.

“I’m very pleased it’s finally been resolved but our neighbours appear to not be too happy.

“It’s a big weight off our shoulders. We’re quite happy with our little wooden house breeding alpacas, which we’ve done for 20 years. That’s all we’ve ever wanted.”

Karl Eckert, Mrs Hodgson’s brother, said: “People have always lived in that house. There will be an uproar if it’s knocked down.

“To demolish bricks and mortar for a wooden hut doesn’t make sense.”

The Guardian has submitted a Freedom of Information request to reveal how much the White Peak Alpaca Farm planning battle has cost council tax payers over the last six years.