Plant faces opposition in villages

Residents protest against the biogas facility at Twemlow                                                                                          n122571 Residents protest against the biogas facility at Twemlow n122571

A FORMER Ministry of Defence (MoD) depot, which dates back to the Cold War, could be transformed into a power plant.

Ray Brown, of Orchards Farm, wants to build a biogas facility at the former fuel storage site in Twemlow Lane, Twemlow.

If planning permission is granted, the plant will use a process called ‘anaerobic digestion’ to break down slurry and food waste to create green energy.

But Mr Brown, whose family has lived at Orchards Farm since 1961, has a fight on his hands, as a campaign group has been set up to oppose it.

Concerns have been raised about ‘appalling smells’ from manure and food waste, noise from generators and country lanes ‘clogged’ with extra vehicle movements under 30m from the nearest home.

A spokesman for Twemlow and Goostrey No To Waste Plant said: “Our main worry is that it would be an industrial scale plant in the middle of a little hamlet.

“Right beside the proposed entrance is a tiny bridge and on the other end is a 90 degree turn. Traffic would be a horrendous problem.

“The smell will also be horrendous. Our environment will be shattered by this.

“No one’s against anaerobic digestion – it’s green energy – but this is a massive thing.”

The 12-acre site is bounded by farmland and the West Coast railway line and is home to six 5,750 cubic metre storage tanks, which would be used to store slurry.

Mr Brown, 52, said: “I’m disappointed that they’ve taken such a negative stance. The great thing about this is that we’re using a brownfield site, and it’s going to take local waste and turn it into local power.

“It will be called the community renewable energy scheme (CRES), as I want the community to get involved and I want the community to get the benefit of it.

“The biggest benefit to farmers locally is that the product left behind when you finish the process makes a really good fertiliser.”

In a letter to residents, Mr Brown said that odorous materials would be transported to site in sealed containers and unloaded in a sealed, negative pressure environment.

The applicant has also clashed with campaigners on traffic figures, with Mr Brown estimating an average of 42 vehicle movements on a working day.

The Twemlow and Goostrey No To Waste Plant group says the plant will create up to 80 vehicle movements.

“I don’t want more traffic either, as I farm on the land,” added Mr Brown.

Mr Brown also told the Guardian that he has hopes in the long term to use the site’s existing pipelines to transport food waste and slurry to lessen the impact on the roads.

The Twemlow Lane site was used by the MoD as a fuel store, from the 1950s to the 1980s and sold by tender in 2010.

l The plans will be on display at Orchards Farm, Twemlow Lane, from 2pm to 9pm, on Monday, July 2.

l Twemlow parish council is meeting on Monday evening, at 7.15pm, at Terra Nova School, when residents will have the chance to ask questions.

Comments(3)

Goostrey Resident says...
10:10am Wed 27 Jun 12

I strongly object to Mr. Brown's assertion that this energy scheme is a community project. “It will be called the community renewable energy scheme (CRES), as I want the community to get involved and I want the community to get the benefit of it." This comment is totally misleading as there is NOTHING for the local community to benefit from here, and they will only be inconvenienced and disadvantaged by increased traffic, noise and light pollution. As a community we will most certainly be involved, but only to object to this scheme. It might well be 'green' but the location is totally wrong. Why not visit Twemlow and see for yourself the narrow lanes, 90 degree turns and busy junctions that all make this project unrealistic? Visit the junction of Hermitage Lane and Twemlow Lane and imagine turning left in a HGV without endangering oncoming traffic? Twemlow and Goostrey are villages, villages do not need a power plant.

Sustainable Future says...
9:49pm Sun 1 Jul 12

After reading the comments above I am struggling to understand why anybody would object to this scheme. Perhaps the local community don't fully understand what is involved. If it did maybe it would remove many of the above concerns so that it would begin to understand how the 'community will benefit'. Anaerobic digestion schemes can actually have little impact on the local environment when designed properly and this one even benefits from existing tanks that are sunk into the ground reducing visual impact. In Germany many villages are now relying on locally produced electricity from cow manures, food waste and maize silage to ensure they are sustainable. Odour is not an issue, vessels are sealed, noise is not an issue as generators are required to be sound attenuated, indeed I would doubt very much if anybody within a few yards of the generators would actually hear them running. Right now I suspect your food waste goes to landfill, I suppose this is okay because this landfill will be in somebody else's backyard!, but imagine a time where your own waste would be used to power your own homes with virtually no impact on the local community. Surely this is the future, a green, sustainable future where the local community benefits and is not porting its problem in somebody else's backyard. I am an ex Twemlow resident and even now only live a few miles away, I know the site well and I also happen to work in the renewable energy industry so understand the technology. Embrace this scheme its exciting and forward thinking. Twemlow and Goostrey are indeed villages but to say 'they do not need a power plant' (rather emotive given what an AD scheme is), is without wishing to be rude a little ignorant. Goostrey/Twemlow need power and are relying on it coming in essence from South Africa and Russia by 2020 there will be an energy gap, how is it to be filled? Your villages will sometime in the future be happy at having a secure locally produced electricity supply. How will the community benefit? Think about it.........

Goostrey homeowner says...
10:33pm Wed 4 Jul 12

Think about it? I can assure you we do, we think of the thousands of vehicles and their emissions carting all the waste from all over Cheshire to our doorstep, how much energy do they use? Growing maize to feed the digester, taking the land out of food production. Local electricity for the community? No, it will be fed into the national grid via Scottish Power. You are right to mention Germany, but they do not put AD plants of this industrial scale right beside homes or near schools.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree